Saturday, 28 April 2007

Areva caught out by plumb crazy rule

While there's not much point in Areva Challenge crying over spilt milk, they must feel a little hard done by after being ruled as Did Not Finish from yesterday's finish line drama against Team Shosholoza.

I'm sure that race officer Peter 'Luigi' Reggio and Bryan Willis's jury are absolutely correct in having determined that Areva's mast tip never recrossed to the course side of the line, and rules is rules. But what a harsh way to lose a point. Natural justice would suggest that if you re-round the finish buoy without hitting it, then that should be sufficient to offload the penalty.

The counter-argument could run that if you don't want to take the risks inherent with using the finish buoy as the place to offload the penalty, then Areva could have taken the 270 degree turn further up the course. Of course that wouldn't have won them the race either because the finish between Shosholoza and the French was close enough as it was, let alone trying to do a penalty before the finish and then sailing the final few metres downspeed with just mainsail and genoa up.

So Areva were damned if they did and damned if they didn't. In the modern media world where audiences demand instant decisions, however, doesn't it make sense to revise this rule rather than have this overnight delay until a jury can make the final decision? Meanwhile, next time Areva have to take a penalty, they should send a man aloft with a very long plumbline hanging from the top of the mast. That way they'll know for sure whether they were clear or not!


Professor Matt said...

And here is the latest news on Areva:

The price of uranium continues to rise and projected demand increases with the expectation of new nuclear build. Having mining rights to uranium deposits is increasingly attractive to nuclear businesses.

The French nuclear giant, AREVA, has offered $2.5 billion to buy the South Africa-based UraMin company. This would give AREVA access to mining and exploration projects in the Central African Republic, South Africa and Namibia.

go to the full article

Anonymous said...

I found the latest news: RE:

French nuclear giant Areva has put together a group of utitilites that want to build its EPR design nuclear power plant in Great Britain, but the company that holds most of the nuclear sites in the UK, British Energy, is backing all of the horses in the race and keeping its cards close to its chest!

click here for the full article